Cashmere Wrap
Whether layered under a coat for warmth or worn as a blanket on a plane, this scarf outperforms the rest.
$178 at J.CrewLancôme Rénergie Duo
There are few products that Katie has used for years, but this Lancôme moisturizer has staying power.
$268 at QVCGiza Cotton Sheets
Katie's so committed to this bedding, she recently put it on nearly every bed in her Hamptons home.
$120 at QuinceFlorence Earrings
These mini hoops make a major statement. Katie already owns them in gold and now she's eyeing them in silver.
$128 at Jenny BirdGinger Peach Green Tea
If you need a quick gift in a pinch, copy Katie: Make a basket including this tea and an adorable mug.
$14 at AmazonFlynn Cashmere Sweater
Jenni Kayne sweaters aren’t just a mainstay in Katie’s wardrobe — they’ve become her go-to gift for the people she loves most.
$244 at Jenni KayneThe Hero Kit
A makeup minimalist’s dream, this kit includes five Jones Road bestsellers, for a fresh, polished look in minutes.
$86 at Jones RoadEberjey Gisele PJ Set
There are a few reasons Katie's obsessed with these pajamas: They’re unbelievably soft, breathable, and never clingy.
$158 at EberjeyCashmere Sweater
A high-quality sweater at a low price: At only $50, grab one for yourself, too.
$50 at QuinceTravel Jewelry Case
You can’t beat the price on this jewelry case. Buy in bulk and you're set for the season.
$7 at AmazonAerotrunk Compression Cubes
Packing a suitcase won't feel like a mental and physical battle with these compression cubes.
$40 at AmazonLucy Wristlet
A card case that comes in a million colors — you'll certainly find one to suit your giftee.
$35 at Kate SpadeLuggage Tag
This designer accessory will help them keep tabs on their possessions, in style.
$19 at CoachWater Bottle Crossbody
They already own a water bottle, but do they own a sleek bag designed to carry it?
$48 at lululemonRechargeable Hand Warmers
When you can’t hold their hand, they’ll appreciate having this gadget to reach for.
$28 at AmazonPure Color Lipstick Duo
The packaging of this silky red lipstick duo is so pretty, they'll want to hang it from their tree.
$42 at Estée LauderFeatherless Quilted Jacket
This lightweight jacket will keep them comfortable even when temperatures hit single digits.
$100 at QuinceDiptyque Carousel
Forget snow globes — this is the grown-up version of holiday wonder.
$110 at NordstromAlign Leggings
Beloved by fitness fiends and couch potatoes alike, these leggings can do no wrong.
$108 at lululemonBubble Initial Necklace
Think Carrie Bradshaw's nameplate necklace with a playful upgrade.
$58 at BaubleBarBirkenstock Naples
If loafers and clogs had a love child, it would be these stylish Birkenstocks.
$165 at AnthropologieBreda Jane Watch
For those who prefer an old-fashioned timepiece, try this viral TikTok find.
$195 at Nordstrom“Star of the Show”
Just like Dolly herself, her new book is full of wit, wisdom, and a whole lot of heart.
$52 at BookshopCrown Comfort Pullover
Molner loves this sweater so much, he bought a dozen to give all of his friends.
$155 at Peter MillarLeather Duffel
Replace the ratty gym bag he says is "good enough" for business trips. (It's not.)
$200 at QuinceØriginalGrand Oxfords
Katie gifted these to Molner in June, and they’ve been in steady rotation ever since.
$112 at Zappos“Outlive” by Peter Attia, MD
They don't have to be into biohacking to benefit from this life-changing book.
$18 at AmazonZ700 Vest
He'll be able to swing and stroll without missing a beat in this Molner-approved piece.
$168 at Zero RestrictionGolf Wingman GPS Speaker
This magnetically attaches to a golf cart, plays music, and doubles as a GPS rangefinder.
$110 at AmazonMagGo 3-in-1 Charger
The antidote to a cluttered nightstand? A charging dock that juices up to three devices.
$60 at AmazonABC Trousers
Meet the pants that ruined jeans for men everywhere. Molner wears these almost daily.
$138 at lululemonFaux Fur Knit Cloche Hat
The cloche hat is making a comeback, and this one has a warm and fuzzy upgrade.
$48 at AnthropologieFair Isle Cardigan
Is this the quintessential winter sweater? We certainly prefer it over something with an elf on it.
$138 at J.CrewItalian Leather Shoulder Bag
Quince's leather bag is a triple threat: fashionable, functional, and easy on the wallet.
$140 at QuinceEleanor Band
With a Tory Burch band, suddenly that smartwatch looks like a classic timepiece.
$240 at Tory BurchFinley Wool Coat
A sleek investment coat like this will not only last a lifetime, it'll never look dated.
$598 at Brochu WalkerIn The Cards Silk Scarf
Bellissima! When they wrap themselves in this silk scarf, they'll feel like Sophia Loren.
$179 at EchoBondi 9 Sneakers
Katie's favorite Hoka sneakers have cloud-like cushioning that feels like walking on air.
$175 at ZapposKhiry x J.Crew Earrings
They'll feel extra glam in these red-carpet-worthy yet affordable gold earrings.
$90 at J.CrewHoliday Blockbuster Gift Set
This gift set is valued at over $600, with nine full-sized products.
$90 at Esteé LauderAmber Solid Perfume
Transport them to Paris — without paying for airfare or hotels.
$76 at Bloomingdale'sLe Chouchou Lip Balm
This gloss is beloved by beauty editors because it’s healing, plumping, and butter-scented.
$24 at EADEMSoft Services Theraplush
Soft Services partnered with DedCool for an It-girl gift that's bound to sell out.
$74 at Soft ServicesTheragun Mini
Taking care of your body should always come first, and this tiny tool makes it easy.
$220 at QuinceThe Party Kit
Like Katie, we're obsessed with Jones Road Beauty. Grab this to try its greatest hits.
$62 at Jones RoadEmbellished Spa Set
This soft set will make their skincare routines mess-free — and add sparkle.
$26 at AnthropologieILIA Clean Makeup Set
Curated for a five-minute face, this has everything needed for a quick and pretty pick-me-up.
$49 at iliaShaggy Dog Crew
Alex Mill combined forces with J.Press for a fuzzy sweater that'll look adorable on him.
$275 at Alex MillKoolaburra Slippers
These suede slippers were made for long walks from the kitchen to the living room.
$75 at QVCSony Headphones
A favorite of John and Katie’s, Sony’s headphones are great for long-haul flights.
$200 at AmazonCustom Engraved Bracelet
Personalize this leather cuff with his initials or birthstone and he'll feel extra loved.
$162 at JewlrCalvin Klein Boxers
Soft where it counts, sleek where it matters, and guaranteed to support him.
$25 at Nordstrom RackCashmere Sweater
Sustainably sourced and thoughtfully crafted, this will be a gift they'll wear for years.
$60 at QuinceStargazing Kit
Transform lunar halos, Martian ice caps, and sun dogs into front-row experiences.
$68 at Bespoke PostOn Roger Advantage Sneakers
As smooth as Roger Federer, these sneakers deliver high-tech support with timeless style.
$160 at Zappos7-Layer Caramel Cake
This seven-layer caramel cake was Katie’s dad’s favorite, so it comes highly recommended.
$70 at Caroline's CakesYiayia and Friends EVOO
Your giftee is guaranteed to feel like a pro chef with this Greek-made, chili-infused olive oil.
$25 at Bespoke PostEstelle Coupes
Katie gifts Estelle's glasses to all her pals for champagne, mocktails, and more.
$205 at AnthropologieSilicone Spatula Set
GIR's utensil collection isn't only spunky, it's also BPA-, BPS-, and phthalate-free.
$70 at GIREuropean Linen Napkins
Thick, high-quality, and gorgeous, these linens are for the eco-conscious host.
$70 at QuinceRoyal Riviera Organic Pears
Katie says: “I often send these to my extended family, and so far, no complaints!”
$55 at Harry & DavidStaub Cast Iron Braiser
For the host who goes wild for picture-perfect holiday tablescapes.
$200 at Williams SonomaTruffle-Infused Hot Sauce
These fancy-feeling condiments prove that hot sauce can be a gourmet experience.
$18 at TruffApple AirPods Pro 3
The tech titan's latest drop is *the* gift of the year — and sound as good as they look.
$249 at AmazonPavé Apple Watch Band
Upgrade their existing Apple Watch with a stainless steel bracelet and a touch of glam.
$60 at QuinceHP Sprocket Printer
Bring back IRL photo albums and framed memories with a pocket-sized printer.
$110 at QVCCharging Station
This sleek and subtle dock makes a dead battery feel a little less tragic.
$90 at AmazonKindle Scribe
Reading, note-taking, and doodling come together in Amazon’s newest e-reader.
$450 at AmazonHatch Sound Machine
Our editors swear by this device to achieve sound sleep when traveling.
$40 at NordstromAirTag Bag Charm
Want a little more whimsy than a plain AirTag can provide? Hide it in this kitschy charm.
$24 at AnthropologieSculptural Charger
This eye-catching accessory has a game-changing secret: a retractable cord.
$44 at CounterpartLoewe Tomato Leaves Soap
This ultra-viral gift evokes a stroll through a summer garden, even in the dead of winter.
$85 at Neiman MarcusDarian Chelsea Boots
These water-resistant boots are easy on the feet but tough on the ground.
$130 at NordstromSuitcase Bundle
Ditch the two-wheeled relic with the sticky handle and busted zipper. Your back will thank you.
$290 at QuinceC E Ferulic Serum
Our editors rely on this formula to fade dark spots and soften fine lines.
$185 at DermstoreMonogram Trinket Box
At under $20, this dish is the kind of whimsical find you’ll want to keep for yourself.
$18 at AnthropologieLuka Duffel
Meet your new grab-and-go sidekick for everything from gym sessions to overnight trips.
$110 at CalpakShark Wandvac Stick Vacuum
Jennifer Garner told us she uses one of these to suck up spilled flour and spices in her kitchen.
$130 at WayfairChristmas Cactus
Hardy enough for black thumbs, a holiday cactus rewards minimal care with bright blooms.
$49+ at The SillDesign and graphics by Mel Haasch