The Best-Reviewed Fall Fashion We Found on Amazon

$170 (20% off)

We were just as surprised as you probably are to see high-quality cashmere like this on Amazon. It’s made from 100 percent sustainable Mongolian cashmere, it won’t pill, and it’s lightweight enough to wear under another layer. 

$95 (61% off)

Katie is obsessed with loafers, and we have a feeling she might add this pair to her collection. This penny loafer is made with sustainable materials, including an antimicrobial, anti-odor insole made from algae-infused foam. On top of that, it just so happens to be 61 percent off.

$33 (20% off)

Here’s a thicker alternative to the viral Intimissimi top, but with even more cashmere and for half the price. We’re declaring this shirt a layering essential, with a boatneck silhouette that looks good on any decolletage.

$15 (15% off)

Katie always keeps a pair of gold earrings in rotation. They instantly upgrade an outfit, and for less than $15, you might as well get them in all three metals (gold, rose gold, and silver).

$239 (30% off)

Katie has a roster of wide-leg jeans in her closet, and Paige is a brand she always goes back to. This wide-leg pair is similar to a style she already owns, but this is in a classic wash you can wear year-round. Copy her style and dress them up with heels, or style them casually with a pair of retro sneakers — like the ones we found below.

$45 (15% off)

Retro-inspired sneakers are having a moment, but perhaps you want something outside of the Adidas Gazelle box. To stand out in a sea of three-striped shoes, opt for this brandless style, which pairs well with denim or even trousers.

$60 (20% off)

When not on stage or at a work event, Katie lives in supportive sneakers like Hokas, and we found the affordable, Amazon alternative. Don’t just take our word for it, because reviewers claim that it’s the best off-brand walking sneaker: “I was skeptical because I found them on TikTok, but after wearing them for a week and standing 8-10 hours, I can say they have very good support, the style is pretty versatile, and it gave me an inch in height.”

$48 (31% off)

This jacket is lightweight yet insulating, with a quilted front and breathable sleeves that flatters and moves with you. Wear it for walks, jogs, errands, or travel — it won’t lose its shape or get lumpy.

$98 (15% off)

Katie loves her Barbour jacket, and so do we, but this less-expensive Levi’s style is currently on our wish list. Its wine color and slightly boxy fit feels a little more modern, and a little less homestead.

$70 (20% off)

Soft, supple leather for less than $70? You betcha. This high-quality tote is one of the best accessories we’ve spotted on Amazon, and looks way more expensive than it is. “Seriously good quality, glad I took a chance on this purse,” notes one reviewer. You should take the chance, too.

$50 (20% off)

When the weather is up and down, a cozy vest will protect your chest from the chill without suffocating you from fingertip to fingertip. This style is far from the sportier styles Molner prefers, with a faux shearling lining that’s cozy and current.

Corduroy is the unofficial fabric of fall, and this oversized blazer will look great over jeans, a dress, or even workout gear if you’re on the run. It comes in nine colors, but we’re gravitating toward this pumpkin spice hue to channel our favorite seasonal beverage.

When it comes to footwear that looks and feels good, Naturalizer is the brand to beat. These stylish boots are a bit pricey, but the quality of the leather and contoured soles mean you’ll be able to wear these boots for hours and own them for years.

$60 (50% off)

No one’s pulling the wool over your eyes: These genuine suede shearling platform boots are a third of the price some brands charge. And they look and feel exactly the same. We don’t know how they do it, but we do know we’re adding them to our cart.

This belt bag is scary similar to more expensive styles, but it’s just as high-quality and wearable. For $13 a pop, feel free to grab one in each color (of which there are a whopping 42 to choose from).

$10 (15% off)

Don’t underestimate this simple accessory; a belt can make or break an outfit — and your bank account. What if we told you we found a sturdy yet buttery option that looks and feels like real leather, for less than the price of a cocktail? The unusual, sculptured buckle on this pick makes it a stylish, outfit enhancer — not just a tool to keep your pants in place.

There’s no need to invest in an expensive watch to upgrade your look. Just swap out the band for a seasonally appropriate tortoise shell one instead.

$100 (30% off)

Orolay is the brand behind that viral multi-pocketed puffer coat from 2018, and its offerings have gotten better with time. This chic trench coat has a more classic look that’s compatible with any outfit.

$50 (28% off)

There’s something cozy and nostalgic about corduroy that has us returning to it year after year. These pants are functional and fashionable: They’ll keep you warm, and they’ve got a slight retro flair without feeling too costume-y. 

$13 (42% off)

We all need to replace our tights more often than we’d like. If you want to extend their lifespan, the only option is to go with a trusted, household name like Hanes. One buyer exclaims, “​​They fit perfectly and are smooth and durable. Clothes do not cling to them. The best part is there is a tag so that you can tell the front from the back.” If you’ve ever spent a day in backward tights by accident, you know how game-changing that detail can be. 

$60 (26% off)

Your jeans, your work pants, your “I just threw this on” dress — they all look better with these classic, clean Chelsea boots.

By now, you’ve heard of shackets. Not quite sweaters, not quite jackets, these fun pieces of outerwear are the perfect half-step between “too warm” and “too cold.” This pick has that polished yet cozy look, in an unexpected blue plaid that feels slightly fresher than old lumberjack prints.