Our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide for 2024

Creative and Thoughtful Jewelry to Give This Valentine’s Day

a collage of jewelry

KCM

Necklaces, rings, earrings, and more at every price point

Products you buy through our links might earn us a commission. We update links when possible, but please note that all prices are subject to change.

Give your loved one the gift of shining bright like a diamond (yes, just like Rihanna) with one of these beautifully crafted pieces of jewelry. We know — jewelry is sort of an obvious Valentine’s Day gift. But if you choose carefully, it doesn’t have to be. You just have to shop with your gift recipient in mind (sometimes that’s just you, and that’s absolutely wonderful) and dig a little deeper to find brands or designs that are unique.

If that sounds intimidating, have no fear — we’ve done a lot of the work for you. For this Valentine’s Day, we’ve rounded up a list of rings, necklaces, earrings, and more that are both high-quality and won’t break the bank. The list consists of items that are unique and brands with interesting backstories that your gift recipient will undoubtedly appreciate. From a personalized heart necklace from Gorjana to a ring made from 100 percent recycled gold, we have a bauble for every type of jewelry lover.

Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gifts

KBH Reclaimed Triple Stack Ring

Made by New York-based KBH Jewels, this ring was handcrafted with 100 percent recycled gold. KBH Jewels believes in wearing pieces you can be proud to pass on; it’s a sustainable, female-founded brand that’s committed to clean material-sourcing, quality, and craftsmanship. The Triple Stack Ring comes in rose gold, white gold, and yellow gold. So give the gift that gives back this Valentine’s Day with this lovely everyday piece. 

Buy Here

Gorjana Bespoke Wilder Heart Necklace

If you’re looking for something that says, “I love you” but doesn’t strain your wallet, try this Bespoke Heart Necklace by Gorjana. It’s lightweight and goes great with just about anything. You can even personalize it with a custom engraving like a name, date, or place. Gorjana, a California-based designer, believes in making jewelry that you’ll live in, love always, and layer every day. Wear this heart necklace with these 18k gold plated Beau Studs

Buy Here

Aurate Lightweight Gold Hoop Earrings Trio

Meet the jewelry line that believes in fine jewelry at a fair price. Aurate is a New York-based company that doesn’t believe in the industry trend of over-the-top markups. This set of gold hoops traditionally goes for $572. With Aurate, you can get the same high-quality craftsmanship for $220 — all of their pieces are made with durable materials built for everyday wear and tear. Try the light-as-air recycled gold hoops in three sizes.

Buy Here

Golden Thread Heroic Strength Necklace

So many of us know someone whose life has been impacted by cancer. At Stand Up To Cancer, researchers and experts receive funding that allows them to collaborate and focus on advancing new therapies and cancer-fighting strategies. (Katie is incredibly proud of the work they do.) Show some love to SU2C this Valentine’s Day by purchasing this Heroic Strength Necklace. Made by Golden Thread founder Jennifer Welker, this collection was created exclusively for SU2C to encourage those on their journey in defeating cancer. Jennifer was a former ICU nurse before starting her jewelry line and believes in celebrating and honoring the courage, perseverance, and strength every patient needs. Plus, each piece in the Stand Up To Cancer Collection can be engraved with your or your loved one’s name. 

Buy Here

Brinker & Eliza Little Love Huggie

This jewelry line was founded by mother-daughter duo Brinker and Eliza Higgins, and all of the brand’s jewelry is handmade in their hometown Connecticut studio. This heart-shaped huggie earring is made with freshwater cultured pearls and ideal for every day wear. It’s the piece in your jewelry box that won’t fail to make you smile.

Buy Here

Lori Weitzner Lina Bracelet

Make a statement this Valentine’s Day with this double wrap beaded bracelet. All of Lori Weitzner’s pieces are hand-stitched and beautifully made. Katie owns a pair of her statement earrings, and we have our eyes on this bracelet, the accessory that’ll spice up your go-to outfit. The designer, Lori Weitzner, has traveled to all corners of the globe in search of materials and inspiration. This bracelet features a row of linear beads that are sealed with a button and loop.

Buy Here

ElyseRyan World Cancer Day Bracelet

Honor a loved one or special friend this Valentine’s Day with the ElyseRyan World Cancer Day bracelet. Elise Rosenstock, designer of ElyseRyan Jewelry, crafts beautiful jewelry that works from day to night. Her pieces are inspired by art, travel, and a love of color; no two bracelets are the same. These pieces of art create a conversation around every individual’s story, with the hope of raising greater awareness for the cause. 

Buy Here

Elyse Ryan Serenity Golden Pearls

For a classy single bracelet or a luxe stack, gift these gold and freshwater pearl pieces from ElyseRyan. The beads are solid 14K gold, giving the bracelet a nice weight, and the freshwater pearls are polished and shaped into perfect spheres. Designer ElyseRyan is known for her understated, elegant designs — this set was inspired by the jewelry she often saw her grandmother wearing.

Buy Here

Made By Mary Heart Disc Necklace

Sometimes less is more, and this little heart charm is no exception. The charm is only 3/8″ wide, making it a dainty addition to any outfit or an excellent pieces to layer alongside others. The heart is hand-stamped and made in the USA. It also comes in three colors (gold, rose gold, and silver), so you can guarantee that it’ll match your giftee’s style. And at under $50, you could even buy multiple for family members or friends, for a grown-up friendship-necklace moment.

Buy Here

Gorjana Classic Diamond Necklace

A simple diamond is a piece that not only goes with everything, but lasts forever. This stunner features a bevel-set, round-cut diamond surrounded by a 14K gold chain. It oozes elegance, and sits right on the collarbone for a delicate look. It could easily be worn alone or layered with other necklaces, but either way, chances are this is item the jewelry lover in your life will be donning every single day.

Buy Here

Able Forever Ring

For a simple statement, this delicate knot ring symbolizes the strong bond between you and a loved one. This minimal piece is great for everyday wear or stacking. Plus, it costs less than $50, making it a great gift for you and your daughters, family members, or friends. Buy matching rings for a few of them, to remind one another of the love you share.

Buy Here