Katie has a solid sense of what belongs in her wardrobe — and what can stay on the rack. She knows what works for her, sticks with the pieces she loves, and doesn’t let every new trend send her down a shopping spiral. Her fall picks are largely the things you want to keep close: great jeans, soft cashmere, polished flats, and jewelry that can pull an outfit together without much fuss.
That doesn’t mean she’s playing it safe. Caped jackets, sporty sneakers, and a few other pieces bring her cheeky personality to the mix.
So what made the cut? These are the pieces Katie's wearing and recommending this fall, along with a few additions we think would fit right in. It’s an exclusive first look inside her closet, because we’re sure she’ll have a few more recommendations before the season ends.
Low Rise '90s Loose Jeans
Gap
The Hailey Bieber x Gap collection sold out way too fast, so Katie has settled on this vintage-inspired style instead. The fit is loose without veering into sloppy territory, and the shorter inseam works particularly well on a smaller frame. Consider it proof that finding the right jeans is less about chasing the latest silhouette and more about knowing what works on you.
Jennifer Fisher Hoops
Jennifer Fisher
If there’s one piece of jewelry Katie wears nearly every day, it’s a hoop earring. These Jennifer Fisher ones are lightweight enough to keep her lobes from complaining by the end of the day, and they don’t irritate her sensitive skin, either.
Madewell Brown Suede Boots
Madewell
Katie often opts for a little extra height, and these boots deliver without sending her teetering around town. The chunky heel adds an inch or two, while the pointed toe creates a longer line through the leg. Wear them under flared jeans for a little lift or let them peek out beneath a midi skirt.
LOFT Perfect Tank
LOFT
As the name implies, this really is a near-perfect piece of clothing. She owns this tank in multiple colors, thanks to a soft, breathable fabric that holds its shape instead of giving up halfway through the day. Wear it solo while the weather cooperates, then tuck it under sweaters and blazers once the temperature drops.
J. Crew Cashmere Sweater
J.Crew
A good cashmere sweater earns its keep. Katie wears hers traditionally, but also ties it around her shoulders or waist when she wants an extra layer without actually putting one on. A crewneck is especially versatile: Layer it over a collared shirt for the office, or wear it with a tank or T-shirt for a more relaxed look.
adidas Gazelles
adidas
Some days, a sneaker is less a fashion choice and more a necessity. Katie’s adidas Gazelles are up for the job, with enough comfort for a day of errands and a streamlined shape that works with more than jeans. The maroon shade is another point in their favor — unexpected enough to be interesting, neutral enough to play nicely with the rest of your closet.
Anthropologie Avec Les Filles Cape Jacket
Anthropologie
Sometimes the jacket is the outfit. This cropped trench makes the case with a playful cape silhouette that adds interest without going too far in the precious direction. The gingham pattern on the collar and cuffs gives the otherwise classic shape a little thrill, so the rest of the outfit can remain relatively simple.
Vince Camuto Loafers
DSW
One of the simplest ways to change the mood of a casual outfit? Trade sneakers for loafers. This pair from Vince Camuto is made from buttery-soft suede that only gets better with wear, while the square toe gives the classic shape a more current feel. It’s a small switch, but one that can make jeans and a sweater look considerably more intentional.
AYR Striped Morning Tee
AYR
If your T-shirt drawer is starting to look like a sea of solids, add a stripe. Katie wears hers with a chunky gold necklace or oversized hoops, letting the pattern provide some visual interest while the jewelry does the rest. It’s a small change, but sometimes that’s all an outfit needs.
